Episode #169: How to find authentic restaurants in Rome

This article may contain compensated links. See our full disclosure here

untold italy app

 

Listen to “How to Find Authentic Restaurants in Rome and Beyond” on Spreaker.

LISTEN ON APPLE LISTEN ON STITCHER LISTEN ON SPOTIFY

Eating in Rome can unquestionably be a wonderful experience, but as with any popular tourist destination, it is, unfortunately, a place where you’ll find tourist traps and places that serve dishes that would make any Italian despair! Luckily there are some signs to look out for to help tell if an eaterie is good or bad. We learn from a Rome food expert to always follow the locals and about some staples of Roman cooking and eating. With a little knowledge and effort, you can make sure you avoid the tourist traps and find the real gems in the Eternal City. 

Show notes
We are joined by food tour host, chef, sommelier, and all-round food and drink guru Nesim Bekalti of Full Belly Tours. Nesim grew up in the Testaccio district which is known as the kitchen of Rome. Having lived and worked all over the world as a chef he has now returned to his old neighborhood and is keen to share its treasures with others. He not only has a wealth of knowledge but an infectious passion for the cuisine of Rome and Italy. Nesim offers immersive tours in the Testaccio neighborhood: Experience Testaccio includes a delicious breakfast as well as tasting your way around the famous Testaccio Market, with a local. Testaccio Full Immersion includes 12 or more tastings of many of Rome’s traditional delicacies and can be enjoyed in the daytime or as an evening tour, both ending with a trip to Nesim’s favorite childhood (and the neighborhood’s oldest) gelateria. Nesim can also do private and custom tours for you. Untold Italy can attest to how great Nesim’s tour is – how much he can teach you and how mind-blowingly good the food he finds for you is. In this episode, Nesim shares his tips on how to find the best and most authentic eateries for a true and delicious Roman experience. We talk plastic picture menus, pigeon-pleasing display tables, the peculiarity of parmesan wheels, and how walking a little further away from the tourist center or heading down mysterious alleyways can be the key to finding the Eternal City’s greatest food treasures. 

Meet Nesim…

What you’ll learn in this episode

  1. Nesim was working as a food tour guide working for another tour operator when Katy and he first met in 2019. After the pandemic hit and all tours had stopped, when things started to pick up, Nesim started to work for another tour operating doing historical golf car tours. This particular operator wasn’t doing any food tours so sent some people to Nesim. This is when he got a taste (pun intended) for food tours, mixing his passion, knowledge, and background in food and drink with his love of people. He loved building his own itineraries and choosing what and where to eat. This led to him starting Full Belly Tours and he hasn’t looked back since
  2. Nesim comes from a cooking background and he’d hear people say “if you do what you love in life, you don’t work a day in your life”. While that can apply in kitchens, it’s also a high-pressure environment – it’s physically taxing and stressful work, so it definitely feels like you’re working. Doing food tours, he can’t believe his luck – he gets to meet interesting people from all over the world that love food and gets to talk incessantly about food and drink, which is what he does on his own time anyway
  3. Nesim’s father is from Tunisia (Nesim means ‘the breeze’ in Arabic) and his mother is French, though raised in the US. Nesim was born in Washington DC and shortly after his parent moved to Rome, where he grew up. So he is both a foreigner and a Roman simultaneously. When he speaks Italian, he has a thick Roman accent, so is always recognized by Italians as Romano! For 2 decades, Nesim’s two passions of cooking and traveling led to him living all over the world and working in restaurants.  Traveling the world has meant he has a great understanding of different cultures, sensibilities, and sensitivities, so he has a unique skill set where he can relate to people from all over the world while relating to the locals – because Romans love Romans. He can help bridge that gap between the various cultures while keeping things light and entertaining
  4. Nesim offers tours in Testaccio (find out more here), as well as offering private and custom tours. Testaccio is a very important neighborhood to Rome when it comes to food. In ancient Rome, it was like the warehouse district, with food being brought in from every corner of the Roman Empire and stored before redistributing throughout the city. Testaccio also gave birth to what we know as traditional Roman cuisine – so it’s a dining destination for all Romans who come specifically to eat. Neism grew up in Testaccio and also lives there now, so the places that you visit on his tours are the places that he goes to eat and shop on a daily basis. They’re basically the best of the best because they’re the best places in the best neighborhood in Rome to eat. It’s like visiting friends from Nesim so there’s always lots of hugging, kissing and joking – lots of fun for everyone involved
  5. There are three main categories of Italian restaurants – trattoria, osteria, and ristorante. A trattoria is entry-level with no fuss. It’s just good home-cooked, stick-to-your-ribs style food with paper tablecloths, not particularly attentive service, which are all seen as good things in Rome. An osteria is a step up. It’s slightly fancier than a trattoria – a midway point between a trattoria and a ristorante. Osterias started out as local watering holes. The name ‘osteria’ comes from the Italian word ‘osti’, which means ‘host’. So you’re being hosted to have a good time and you would go there, hang out with friends, drink wine, and eat simply – maybe some bread and cheese, or maybe they would cook one dish for the day. It was like the local pub. A century ago, people didn’t generally have things like plumbing and living rooms at home – you had multiple generations of families living in very cramped quarters. So the osteria was where you would go and drink your worries away, have fun, and relax. The osteria has now morphed into an eatery that is a fancier affair than a trattoria.
  6. It can get confusing because, for instance, what is widely acclaimed to be the best restaurant in Italy (if not the world) is Osteria Francescana, the three-star Michelin restaurant run by chef Massimo Bottura – which is obviously is more high-end though at the end of the day, you are being ‘hosted’ there. So Osteria doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s not super fancy, but it’s normally going to be less fancy than a ristorante, which is going to be a more formal setting. Usually, a restaurant will have a white tablecloth, the waiters will often be in three-piece suits with ties. Nesim advises you’ll tend to find the best food in Italy in trattorias and osterias. When Italians start fussing with food, plating on larger plates with squiggles of sauce, tweels, and other paraphernalia, they lose that magical, soul-satisfying quality that classic Italian food has. So when in doubt – go for a trattoria and osteria
  7. The more rustic an establishment looks, the better. If it looks like they haven’t renovated the place in over 70 years, then that’s a very good sign. These places seem to always have one main focus. If that focus is on food, they’ll make really good food and won’t feel the need to fancy up the environment because if the food is delicious – it says it all
  8. As well as decor, marketing is also usually not the main focus. The chances of them having a website is quite slim. it is more common for businesses to have a Facebook page instead of a website. You’re not going to find these places on Google which is why it’s really important to get these top tips on how to find great, authentic eateries.
  9. If you’re trying to call any Italian business and they don’t answer their phone, it by no means implies that they’re closed. There’s just a different approach to customer service in Italy – Nesim says (half-jokingly) that the customer is rarely right in Italy. If no one answers your call, just keep trying or perhaps just go and show up in person
  10. Many people’s trips begin and end in Rome, or they will spend some time in Rome. Sometimes you can luck out and stumble on a great restaurant but it’s often you’re led to somewhere that’s not so great. There are lots of places that have done a decent job of their marketing but are not the greatest for food. For example, places that you’ll easily find online, in media articles and are famous on Instagram. There is a very famous sandwich shop that’s just opened behind the Pantheon called All’Antico Vinaio which is a sandwich shop from Florence. It’s very famous on Instagram for its very large sandwiches and people queue up outside this shop. A red flag that no locals are there is that Romans don’t really queue. If they do, it is not in an orderly fashion – they congregate in a large mass outside of the dining establishment, trying to elbow past or catch the eye of the staff. The sandwiches at All’Antico Vinaio are good but probably not good enough to wait hours in line for, especially in Rome as Italian food is super regional. All’Antico Vinaio in Florence is probably going to be slightly better because it’s where it originates
  11. Italy is a fairly new country – it was only unified as a Republic in 1861. Prior to that, it was a bunch of independent city-states that were often at war with each other and didn’t necessarily trade – especially food. You had to be wealthy – the clergy or nobility, to bring in food from other parts of the country. This is food is so regional in Italy – every 10/15 miles, you’ll find a new pasta shape, cheeses, wines, and cold cuts. This is why it’s so great, culinary wise to travel around Italy
  12. No matter where you are in Italy, they’ll of course tell you that the other regions are wrong. On Nesim’s tours, he may tell you all sorts of things, and then you’ll go up to Bologna and they’ll be like, “Oh, that Roman guy has no idea what he’s talking about!”. As long as you listen to the locals, you’ll have the best possible local experience
  13. Rome has a crazy number of visitors each year, which means that unfortunately there are a lot of tourist traps. People prey on visitors who may think “I’m in Italy, everything is going to be good here”. That does usually apply to anywhere where there aren’t crowds of tourists. In any small town you venture to, you’ll eat well because it’s basically Italians cooking for other Italians. When you have the anonymity of the masses or when they’re cooking for visitors they often start using lower quality ingredients and it may even be people that don’t even know how to cook properly. Rome is possibly the hardest place to find good food in Italy
  14. Nesim recommends that if you’re going to the Vatican, or the Colosseum – those tourist hubs, have breakfast before heading out there, and then do a little research and plan to travel to a neighborhood nearby to eat

Red flags & tips on what to avoid

No one wants to eat bad food in Italy, but it is possible in Rome, so check out our tips on what to look out for

  • You need to walk a minimum of five blocks from the closest tourist attraction before you start looking for food. The larger and more important the attraction – the further away you need to walk. If you are within walking range of St Peter’s, chances are that’s not a good place to look for food. There are some small places that have managed to survive, but for the most part, it is tourist traps
  • Rather than heading to a specific neighborhood to go to (although Testaccio is an amazing place to eat) it’s mostly about avoiding the super crowded areas
  • There are also visual queues that you can use to see if places are tourist traps or not. One is the display table. Where you have a sad little table outside of the restaurant, often with a pizza or a plate of pasta sat shriveling in the sun. The more cliche the ingredients you see on a table, the more you should worry. For example, piles of dried pasta, clusters of grapes, cherry tomatoes, garlic or chilies and of course, the fiasco, the fat-bottomed bottle of wine with a straw basket on the bottom. That’s the bottle that Chianti used to be served in decades ago. Chianti is just sold in regular wine bottles nowadays
  • Near the display table, you’ll also often find what’s called the ‘accalappiacani’ – the catcher. That’s the person outside waving a menu in your face and calling out “My friend, Deutsche? Francais? Espanol?” Just smile and keep walking (or scowl and keep walking)
  • The menu can also tell you a lot. A very large menu sitting outside of a restaurant is very suspicious, especially if it has pictures. You should never find pictures on Italian menus. It’s something that in Italy they use mostly for ethnic cuisine, in part because a lot of Italians aren’t necessarily familiar with lots of ethnic cuisine. By law in Italy – you have to have a menu displayed outside,